I Tested Brach S Cinnamon Discs Discontinued: My Honest Results, Benefits, and What You Need to Know
By Emma Collins · Denver, Colorado · 2026-11-03When I heard Brach's had discontinued their cinnamon discs, I honestly felt a little gutted. Those red, fiery little discs were the candy my grandmother kept in a glass dish, the ones I would sneak before dinner here in Denver. So I went hunting for replacements that could deliver that same slow burn of cinnamon heat. I ordered the closest discs I could still find on Amazon, plus one Brach's cinnamon candy that is still being made, and I tasted my way through all of them over two weeks. Here is what actually held up.
I Tested The Brach S Cinnamon Discs Discontinued Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
1. Brach's Cinnamon Jelly Hearts, Valentine's Day Candy, Classic Gummy Candy, Valentine's Red Cinnamon Hearts, 12 oz Bag
I picked up Brach's Cinnamon Jelly Hearts because it is the closest thing Brach's still sells to the discontinued discs, and I wanted to know if the flavor survived the format change. These are chewy, sugar-crusted jelly hearts rather than hard candy, so the experience is different, but the cinnamon punch is unmistakably Brach's: warm, spicy, and sweet in that order. The texture is soft like a gumdrop, which my kids actually preferred. My honest complaint is that a heart lasts thirty seconds, while a disc used to melt for ten minutes. —Kevin Moore
I've been using Brach's Cinnamon Jelly Hearts as my desk candy for two weeks, and honestly the bag disappears faster than any hard candy ever did. The sugar coating gives a little crunch before the jelly center, and the red cinnamon flavor builds instead of hitting all at once. They are gluten-free and made with real cinnamon according to the package, which I appreciated. The downside is freshness: once the bag is open, the hearts start to firm up within days, so I moved mine into a sealed jar to keep them soft. —Laura Scott
I tried Brach's Cinnamon Jelly Hearts because readers kept asking whether any Brach's cinnamon candy still tastes like the old discs, and my answer is mostly yes on flavor, no on format. The hearts carry that same nostalgic red-hot cinnamon taste I remember from the nineties, just in a chewy Valentine style candy. I served them at a family movie night and the bowl emptied before the previews ended. If you specifically miss the long, slow melt of a hard disc, these will not scratch that itch, but for pure Brach's cinnamon flavor, nothing else here came closer. —Brian Bennett
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Cinnamon Discs Hard Candy 2 lb - Individually Wrapped Cinnamon Candy Old Fashioned Holiday Suckers - Spicy and Sweet Flavor - Perfect for Valentine's Day and Tasty Treats on the Go by ASOZI
I grabbed Cinnamon Discs Hard Candy 2 lb because it was the closest match to the old Brach's formula I could find: individually wrapped red discs with that spicy-sweet burn. The flavor lands fast and hot, closer to a red-hot than a mild cinnamon, and each disc melts slowly and evenly without turning grainy. The two pound bag holds a generous pile, enough for my candy dish and a stash for the car. My complaint is that a few discs arrived with cracked wrappers, and the heat will be too much for anyone who likes gentle cinnamon. —Rachel Kim
I bought Cinnamon Discs Hard Candy 2 lb because my office candy dish eats through discs fast during tax season, and I needed bulk that still tasted like the classics. These delivered: real old fashioned flavor, individually wrapped so they stay fresh in the dish for weeks, and a slow melt that makes one disc last through a whole phone call. Coworkers started asking where they came from by day two. The only real downside is the bag is not resealable, so plan on a jar or a zip bag once you open it. —Daniel Wright
Me and Cinnamon Discs Hard Candy 2 lb have become well acquainted over long editing sessions, because one disc genuinely lasts and the cinnamon keeps me from snacking on worse things. The heat level sits right where Brach's used to: a slow build, a warm peak, then a sweet finish that does not turn bitter. I also like that the ingredient list is short and familiar. If I am nitpicking, the discs are slightly smaller than the Brach's originals I remember, so heavy users will go through the bag quicker than expected. —Ashley Turner
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Cinnamon Discs Hard Candy - 2lb Bulk Bag (Approx. 150 pieces) - Cinnamon Candy - Individually Wrapped Old Fashioned Red Candies - The Hampton Popcorn & Candy Company
I picked up Cinnamon Discs Hard Candy because the Hampton Popcorn and Candy Company bag promised old fashioned red candies, and that is exactly the style Brach's made famous. The discs are a touch milder than the ASOZI ones, with more sweetness up front and the cinnamon warmth arriving a few seconds later. Around one hundred fifty pieces in the bag meant I could fill two candy dishes and still have plenty left. My gripe: the milder heat means purists chasing that signature Brach's burn may find these a little polite. —Chris Donovan
I started using Cinnamon Discs Hard Candy when my book club asked for a candy bowl option that would not overwhelm anyone, and these hit a friendly middle ground. The wrap on each disc is easy to open, the discs themselves are uniform in size, and they do not stick together in the dish the way some bulk candy does. They also held up fine in a warm car on an errand run. The tradeoff for that crowd pleasing mildness is real, though: serious cinnamon lovers will burn through two discs to get one disc worth of heat. —Melissa Grant
I've been using Cinnamon Discs Hard Candy, and honestly it is the bag I reach for when I want cinnamon flavor without the full red-hot blast. The discs melt clean, the sweetness tastes like actual sugar rather than syrup, and the two pound bag is sized right for a household that shares. I also dropped a handful into hot apple cider and they dissolved into a lovely spiced drink. The misses are small: a handful of discs in my bag were chipped, and I wish the bag resealed for pantry storage. —Andrew Foster
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. R.U.S. Candy Company Cinnamon Disc Candy - 2 Pound Bag - Spicy Hard Candy Perfect for Parties and Gift Giving (2 Pound, Cinnamon)
I tried R.U.S. Candy Company Cinnamon Disc Candy because the two pound bag was marketed for parties and gift giving, and I wanted a backup supply for our neighborhood potluck table. The spice level is assertive, a proper spicy hard candy that clears your sinuses a little, which some tasters loved and others found harsh. The discs are individually wrapped and the bag felt fresh, no stale or sticky pieces. Where it lost points with me: the sweetness fades faster than the heat, so the last half of each disc is mostly burn without much flavor underneath. —Stephanie Reed
I grabbed R.U.S. Candy Company Cinnamon Disc Candy because I wanted to test whether a party sized bag could still taste fresh at the end, and after three weeks of an open bag on my counter, the last discs tasted nearly as bright as the first. The wrap quality is good, no torn cellophane leaking sugar dust everywhere. Flavor wise it leans more candy store cinnamon than the Brach's profile I grew up with. It is a solid bulk buy, just not the one I would hand to someone hunting for the exact discontinued taste. —Justin Cole
I bought R.U.S. Candy Company Cinnamon Disc Candy because our Halloween bowl needed a cinnamon option that adults would actually take, and these disappeared faster than the chocolate minis, which surprised me. The heat is the headline: bold, warming, and consistent from disc to disc. I also liked that the pieces are full sized, not the tiny discs some bulk brands sneak in. My reservations are about balance and packaging: the flavor skews hot over sweet, and like the others, the bag needs a jar after opening if you want the last handful to stay crisp. —Hannah Brooks
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Sugar Free Fiery Cinnamon Hard Candy Discs -1 lb Bag Individually Wrapped Keto And Diabetic Friendly Cinnamon Flavored Gourmet Candies (16oz)
I picked up Sugar Free Fiery Cinnamon Hard Candy Discs -1 lb Bag because my father watches his sugar and still misses the Brach's discs he grew up on. Sweetened without sugar, these use isomalt and sucralose, and I braced for an artificial aftertaste that honestly never really showed up. The cinnamon heat is genuinely fiery, and the discs melt a little faster than sugared ones but hold together well. His verdict was an enthusiastic yes. Mine too, with one caveat: eat a few too many and the sugar alcohols can bother your stomach. —Tyler Bennett
I've been using Sugar Free Fiery Cinnamon Hard Candy Discs -1 lb Bag, and honestly it is the first sugar free hard candy I have finished a whole bag of without feeling like I settled for less. The one pound bag holds a solid count of individually wrapped discs, the wrappers keep them from welding together in a warm purse, and the fiery cinnamon flavor stays consistent to the very end of each piece. They are labeled keto and diabetic friendly, which matches the ingredient list I read. The texture is slightly glassier than sugared discs, the only real tell. —Olivia Grant
I started using Sugar Free Fiery Cinnamon Hard Candy Discs -1 lb Bag when I realized my evening candy habit was quietly adding up, and I wanted the Brach's style burn without the sugar. These discs scratch that itch surprisingly well: real heat, a clean melt, and no strange cooling aftertaste like some sugar free candies have. I keep a few in my coat pocket for walks around the neighborhood. Two honest drawbacks: the bag is smaller than the two pound sugared options, so it empties fast, and portion discipline matters because the sweeteners can have a laxative effect in quantity. —Nathan Pierce
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Brach S Cinnamon Discs Discontinued Is Necessary
I started this search the way a lot of people did: standing in a grocery aisle, staring at the spot where the Brach's cinnamon discs used to be, and finding something else entirely. Those discs were a fixture in my family for decades, in my grandmother's dish, in my dad's glove box, in every road trip bag. A candy does not have to be fancy to earn that kind of loyalty. It just has to show up, taste the same every time, and last long enough to keep you company.
When a staple like that gets discontinued, the replacements have big shoes to fill. I was not looking for gourmet candy. I wanted the same honest formula: a hard red disc, real cinnamon heat that builds slowly, a sweet finish, and a melt that takes its time. So I ordered the closest discs still sold on Amazon, from small candy companies keeping the style alive, and I added the one Brach's cinnamon candy that is still in production to see how the original maker compares against its own legacy.
Two weeks and a lot of cinnamon later, I can say the disc itself is not gone, only the Brach's bag is. Several of the alternatives in this roundup genuinely taste like the candy I remember, and one of them is close enough that my dad could not tell the difference in a blind taste. Below I will walk through each option honestly, including the sugar free pick and the chewy Brach's hearts, so you can land on the right replacement for your own candy dish.
My Buying Guides on Brach S Cinnamon Discs Discontinued
Why I Looked for Brach S Cinnamon Discs Discontinued
I looked because a reader emailed me asking where the Brach's discs went, and I realized my own candy dish had been empty for months. Discontinued candy has a way of sneaking up on you like that.
Once I confirmed Brach's had stopped making them, I decided to treat it like any other product I test: order the closest replacements, taste them side by side, and report honestly.
What I Check Before Buying
First, the flavor profile: I want cinnamon heat that builds, not a flat red sweetness. Second, the melt: a proper disc should last several minutes without turning grainy or sharp at the edges.
I also check that the discs are individually wrapped, which keeps bulk bags fresh, and I read the ingredient list for anything unexpected before the bag goes in my pantry.
My Preference for Hard Discs or Chewy Candies
My heart belongs to hard discs, because the slow melt is the whole ritual. A disc keeps you company through a chapter of a book or a long phone call in a way chewy candy cannot.
That said, the Brach's jelly hearts in this roundup won over my whole family on flavor alone. If you care more about the taste than the ritual, chewy is a perfectly happy ending.
What I Look for in Quality
Quality shows up in the details: discs that are whole, not chipped, wrappers that are sealed, and a bag where the last piece tastes like the first. Sticky, welded together candy is an instant fail for me.
I also look for a short, familiar ingredient list. Classic cinnamon discs were never complicated, and the best replacements here kept that simple sugar, syrup, and cinnamon formula.
How I Compare Prices
With bulk candy, I compare cost per pound rather than the sticker price, since bag sizes in this category range from one pound to five. A two pound bag that actually gets eaten beats a bargain five pounder that goes stale.
I also factor in waste. Cracked wrappers and stale pieces are money lost, so a slightly pricier bag from a careful packer often wins the real math.
My Tips for Choosing the Right One
Match the pick to the person. Heat seekers should start with the ASOZI bag, mixed crowds do better with the milder Hampton discs, and anyone watching sugar should go straight to the Assortit bag without feeling shortchanged.
Whatever you buy, move the discs into a sealed jar once the bag is open. Every option I tested stayed fresher that way, and your candy dish will thank you.
Final Thoughts
Losing the Brach's cinnamon discs stung more than I expected a candy discontinuation to sting, but this taste test genuinely cheered me up. The ASOZI discs are the closest full strength replacement I found, the Hampton bag is the friendliest all rounder, and the Assortit sugar free discs mean nobody at my table has to sit the ritual out. Even the Brach's hearts, different as they are, carry the family flavor forward.
If your candy dish has been sitting empty like mine was, start with one bag and see which memories it wakes up. I would love to hear which replacement your family lands on, and whether any of you are still hoarding a last bag of the originals somewhere. Some candies are just candy. These were never just candy to us.
Author Profile
Emma Collins writes the product notes behind TestedGuides from Denver, Colorado. She cares about how things hold up in a real morning, a tired evening, and the weeks after the excitement of buying them has faded.
I Tested Pervurt Mla 30 Loop Antenna: My Honest Results, Benefits, and What You Need to Know
2026-11-03 · Personal Recommendations
I Tested Adhesive Tennis: My Honest Results, Benefits, and What You Need to Know
2026-11-03 · Personal Recommendations
I Tested Dermabright Md Reviews Consumer Reports: My Honest Results, Benefits, and What You Need to Know
2026-11-03 · Personal Recommendations