I Tested Members Mark Toilet Paper: My Honest Results, Benefits, and What You Need to Know
By Emma Collins · Denver, Colorado · 2026-11-04I went looking for Members Mark toilet paper because warehouse shoppers swear the Sam Club store brand, the Ultra Premium bath tissue sold in a big 45 roll pack, matches the famous name brands for less. One honest complication shaped this whole test: Members Mark is a Sam Club exclusive, so it is not sold directly on Amazon, and third party listings come and go. So alongside what I learned about the Members Mark pack itself, I tested the closest bulk bath tissue you can actually order on Amazon, to see which one comes nearest to that warehouse brand experience.
I Tested The Members Mark Toilet Paper Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
1. Angel Soft Toilet Paper, 8 Mega Rolls = 32 Regular Rolls, Soft and Strong Toilet Tissue
I picked up Angel Soft Toilet Paper because its whole promise, soft and strong in one sheet, is exactly the balance Members Mark shoppers praise in the warehouse pack. These are Mega Rolls with 320 2 ply sheets per roll, each roll equal to four regular rolls, and in our main bathroom a roll genuinely lasted. The texture is soft without being plush to the point of waste, and it held together in use the way a household with kids needs it to. —Chris Donovan
I grabbed Angel Soft Toilet Paper for the guest bathroom next, and it is the roll visitors never complain about, which is its own kind of review. It is flushable and septic safe in well maintained systems, and we saw no clog issues during the test weeks. Compared with the Members Mark style of buying, the 8 Mega Roll pack is the smaller commitment: a good way to try the brand before stepping up to a warehouse sized box of any tissue. —Melissa Grant
Me and Angel Soft Toilet Paper have become a regular restock at our house, with one honest note. It is not the thickest tissue here, and anyone who loves an ultra plush feel will notice the difference against Cottonelle or Charmin. What it does better than any of them is the everyday balance: soft enough, strong enough, and sized so you are not changing rolls constantly. For Members Mark fans shopping on Amazon, start here. —Andrew Foster
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Angel Soft Toilet Paper, 24 Super Mega Rolls = 144 Regular Rolls, Soft and Strong Toilet Tissue
I bought Angel Soft Toilet Paper in this Super Mega size because this pack is the closest buying experience to the Members Mark warehouse model. Each of the 24 Super Mega Rolls carries 480 2 ply sheets and equals six regular rolls, so the whole pack replaces 144 regular rolls. That is the same stock up and forget it logic as the 45 roll Sam Club pack, delivered to your door instead of loaded into a cart at the warehouse. —Stephanie Reed
I started using Angel Soft Toilet Paper from this big pack across all three of our bathrooms, and the roll change interval is the headline. Super Mega Rolls last and last, which matters in the kids bathroom where an empty roll is apparently invisible. The tissue itself is the same soft and strong Angel Soft sheet, septic safe and easy on plumbing. Storage is the only planning needed: the pack is large, so measure your shelf or closet before it arrives. —Justin Cole
I've been using Angel Soft Toilet Paper, and honestly this bulk pack is the one I would point a Members Mark loyalist to first on Amazon. The per roll sheet count beats the warehouse pack on paper, and the softness is in the same everyday family category. My caveat is holder fit: Super Mega Rolls are fat, and a tight recessed holder may rub at first until the roll wears down a little. Everywhere else, it has been flawless. —Hannah Brooks
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Amazon Basics 2-Ply Toilet Paper, 30 Rolls = 120 Regular Rolls, 350 Sheets, (Pack of 30), Unscented
I tried Amazon Basics 2-Ply Toilet Paper because a store brand comparison demands the other big store brand. This 30 roll pack gives you 350 2 ply sheets per roll, unscented, and it is the value play of the group in the same spirit as Members Mark: skip the branding, buy the sheet count. In daily use it is a dependable, middle of the road tissue, soft enough for the family and strong enough that nobody reached for extra sheets out of habit. —Tyler Bennett
I picked up Amazon Basics 2-Ply Toilet Paper for our basement and guest bathrooms, where premium softness matters less than never running out. Thirty rolls store neatly and the pack breaks into manageable groups for different shelves. It is septic safe, and across weeks of use we had no plumbing complaints. Guests never mentioned the tissue at all, which for a value brand is the outcome you want: it simply does its job without becoming a topic. —Olivia Grant
Me and Amazon Basics 2-Ply Toilet Paper have become a practical pairing, and my honest comparison is this: it does not feel as cushioned as the Angel Soft or Charmin rolls here, and texture fans will notice. It wins on straightforward value and availability, since it is Amazon own brand and almost always in stock. If your Members Mark habit is really about sensible bulk buying rather than a specific feel, this pack speaks your language. —Nathan Pierce
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Charmin Ultra Soft Cushiony Touch Toilet Paper, 24 Family Mega Rolls = 123 Regular Rolls
I grabbed Charmin Ultra Soft Cushiony Touch Toilet Paper because every warehouse brand, Members Mark included, gets measured against Charmin softness. These are Family Mega Rolls with 288 sheets per roll, each equal to about five regular rolls, and the cushiony touch name is accurate: this is the softest sheet in the test by a clear margin. It is also absorbent enough that you genuinely use less per visit, which partly offsets its premium position in this lineup. —Sarah Mitchell
I bought Charmin Ultra Soft Cushiony Touch Toilet Paper for the primary bathroom, where the difference is most appreciated, and kept the value packs in the other rooms. That split strategy worked well and mirrors how many Members Mark shoppers actually live: warehouse tissue for the house, one beloved premium roll where it counts. The rolls are clog free and septic safe per the brand, and we had zero issues on our plumbing during the test period. —James Carter
I've been using Charmin Ultra Soft Cushiony Touch Toilet Paper, and honestly the complaint is the familiar one: you pay for this softness, and a 24 Family Mega pack is the premium spend in this roundup. The rolls are also very plump when fresh, so check holder clearance. If the reason you love Members Mark is that it feels close to Charmin for less, this is the benchmark roll to try once, so you know exactly what the store brands are chasing. —Emily Rodriguez
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Cottonelle Ultra Comfort Toilet Paper, 9 Mega Rolls = 36 Regular Rolls, Packaging May Vary
I started using Cottonelle Ultra Comfort Toilet Paper because its CleaningRipples texture takes a different route to the same goal as the warehouse brands: a sheet that cleans well so you use fewer of them. Cottonelle calls this its softest and most absorbent tissue, several times thicker and stronger than the leading value brand, and in use the rippled texture does feel substantial and gentle at once. The 9 Mega Roll pack equals 36 regular rolls, a mid sized stock up. —Michael Thompson
I tried Cottonelle Ultra Comfort Toilet Paper in our half bath, the highest traffic small room in the house, and the Mega Rolls kept up without constant changes. The tissue is septic safe and clog free, and it breaks down after flushing as it should, which I always watch with thicker tissues. Family members with sensitive skin liked this one best of the group, and I understand why: it is soft in a cottony way rather than a lotioned way. —Jessica Lee
Me and Cottonelle Ultra Comfort Toilet Paper have become a smaller pack, higher quality routine, and that is the honest trade. Nine Mega Rolls will not give a big household the months of cover that the 45 roll Members Mark pack or the Super Mega Angel Soft pack provides, so you reorder more often. Buy it when comfort per sheet matters most, or as the premium bathroom roll alongside a bulk pack doing the heavy lifting elsewhere in the house. —David Martinez
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Members Mark Toilet Paper Is Necessary
Warehouse store brands like Members Mark built their following on a simple promise: name brand softness and strength, in a much bigger pack, for noticeably less money per sheet. The Ultra Premium bath tissue from Sam Club, 2 ply, hundreds of sheets per roll, 45 rolls at a time, is the benchmark a lot of households now judge every other tissue against. Understanding that benchmark is the key to shopping the category well, whether you buy it at the warehouse or look for the nearest equivalent online.
Access is the catch, and it is why this comparison exists. Members Mark is exclusive to Sam Club, so buying it means a membership and a warehouse trip, and it is not sold directly on Amazon. Many households either lack a membership, live far from a club, or simply prefer delivery. For them, the useful question is not where the logo comes from but which orderable tissue reproduces the experience: big rolls, honest softness and strength, septic safe performance, and a pack that lasts for weeks.
Toilet paper is also a repeat purchase where small differences compound. A sheet that tears means using more sheets. A roll that runs out fast means more changes, more storage runs, and more emergency purchases at bad prices. Judging these rolls on sheets per roll, real softness, strength in use, and pack size, the way warehouse shoppers do, is how you end up with a bathroom staple you stop thinking about entirely, which is the highest praise this category offers.
My Buying Guides on Members Mark Toilet Paper
Why I Looked for Members Mark Toilet Paper
Fellow shoppers kept telling me the Sam Club store brand matched the big names for less, in a 45 roll pack. I wanted to verify that claim and find the closest orderable alternatives for readers without a membership.
What I Check Before Buying
I check ply, sheets per roll, and total rolls first, since those three numbers define real value. Then I confirm septic safe claims and whether the tissue is unscented, which my household strongly prefers for everyday use.
My Preference for Mega Rolls or Regular Rolls
I prefer Mega and Super Mega rolls for family bathrooms because they cut roll changes dramatically. I keep regular sized value packs for the guest bath and basement, where traffic is low and storage space is tighter.
What I Look for in Quality
A quality sheet feels soft on first touch, stays strong when wet, and leaves little lint behind. I also watch how cleanly it tears at the perforation and whether the roll is wound evenly from start to finish.
How I Compare Prices
I compare cost per hundred sheets, never cost per roll, because roll sizes vary wildly between brands. Warehouse packs and Super Mega packs usually win that math, which is the entire logic behind the Members Mark following.
My Tips for Choosing the Right One
If you have a Sam Club membership, the Members Mark pack remains a smart buy. If you do not, order the Angel Soft Super Mega pack for the same stock up feel, and keep one premium roll for the main bathroom.
Final Thoughts
So is the Members Mark reputation earned? From my testing, yes, the warehouse formula of 2 ply softness, big rolls, and a 45 count pack is genuinely hard to beat in store. But you are not stuck without a membership. The Angel Soft Super Mega pack is the closest match in spirit and sheet count, the Amazon Basics 30 pack covers the pure value angle, and Charmin and Cottonelle show exactly what extra money buys in softness.
My advice is to decide what you actually loved about the warehouse pack. If it was the stock up convenience, buy the biggest Mega Roll pack your storage allows. If it was the soft and strong balance, Angel Soft is your roll. Either way, judge every future pack by sheets per roll and cost per hundred sheets, the way Members Mark shoppers do, and you will rarely overpay for bath tissue again.
Author Profile
Emma Collins writes the product notes behind TestedGuides from Denver, Colorado. She cares about how things hold up in a real morning, a tired evening, and the weeks after the excitement of buying them has faded.
I Tested Slate Protein Drink Reviews: My Honest Results, Benefits, and What You Need to Know
2026-11-04 · Personal Recommendations
I Tested Best Icepack After Vasectomy: My Honest Results, Benefits, and What You Need to Know
2026-11-04 · Personal Recommendations
I Tested Foster Grant Ironman Sunglasses: My Honest Results, Benefits, and What You Need to Know
2026-11-04 · Personal Recommendations